I Choose Canada
As many of you Seniors get set to graduate from high school with a few lucky ones the opportunity to play the game you love, I'd like to create some dialogue and discussion on where to play at the next level. The dream of many of course is to get that D1 full-ride scholarship. But I'm here to play devil's advocate and make people think about it a little more.
It's all about the Benjamins
Let's get one thing straight. There is nothing amateur about NCAA sports, especially football and basketball. College football and basketball are multi-billion dollar businesses, corrupt ones at that. Consider that Fox Sports signed a 4-year $80 Million deal to broadcast 4 annual bowl games and the National Title game, and CBS inked an 11-year $6 Billion deal to broadcast March Madness, it's clear that College sports are big business. When you think about all that money floating around, you would think that the student-athletes would get some piece of action. But in fact, it's the student-athletes that can barely cover their costs even with a full-ride scholarship. The hypocrisy that is the NCAA doesn't allow it's students to be sponsored, yet the NCAA sells almost every piece of itself to sweatshop outfits like NIKE, Reebok and Adidas. Something is wrong when the NCAA won't even permit students to get a part-time job on campus forcing many to live in student ghettos.
What about a Free Education?
Unless you receive an athletic scholarship to play at an Ivy League school (of which almost none are competitive in either Football or Basketball with the mild exception of Stanford in Basketball), an undergraduate degree from Canada is just as good if not better that the majority of public or private universities in the US. At least in Canada, schools still pride themselves in their student-athletes academic acheivements. In contrast, a published report by the NCAA showed that recent BCS National Champion LSU graduates only 40 percent of its football players, Oklahoma a pitiful 33 percent. In fact, if schools were required to graduate 50 percent of it's student-athletes, 26 of 28 Bowl games would've been cancelled in 2004. What kind of education are you really getting when student-athletes are faced with waking up for 8am classes after getting back at 3am from a weeknight away game so that ESPN can fill their College Gamenight primetime schedule. Thanks, but no thanks.
I want to go Pro
One of the most idiotic rules ever instituted was the age restriction rule put in place by both the NFL and now the NBA. From a money standpoint, it's great. The pro leagues have a free minor-league system called the NCAA to milk and exploit the "student-athletes" before they get to the pros. If a kid is good enough to go pro, why not go straight from high-school?? With scouting as good as it has ever been, it's the All-Americans that are the ones going pro even after college anyways. The reality nowadays is, if you're not good enough to get to the pros coming out of high school (ie. ranked on Scout.com), you can forget playing in the NFL or NBA.
Closing Thoughts
Don't get me wrong, I love watching College Football and Basketball. The entertainment value is unquestionable, the games are thrilling, the rivalries unmatched, but it stinks from an educational perspective. Money is the ultimate corruptor, the networks and corporate sponsors will do anything and everything to make more of it especially at the expense of you and your education. Are Canadian schools perfect? Hell no. Do I think Canadian schools should offer full-ride scholarships? Absolutely, it's the least they can do to help struggling student-athletes pay the bills. After all, it's not like they're part of the Physics club or something, they're elite athletes for christ's sake. I say, play your sport at a high level, get an education, choose Canada.
As always, post your take or email it to me at BCSportsFanatic@yahoo.ca.
It's all about the Benjamins
Let's get one thing straight. There is nothing amateur about NCAA sports, especially football and basketball. College football and basketball are multi-billion dollar businesses, corrupt ones at that. Consider that Fox Sports signed a 4-year $80 Million deal to broadcast 4 annual bowl games and the National Title game, and CBS inked an 11-year $6 Billion deal to broadcast March Madness, it's clear that College sports are big business. When you think about all that money floating around, you would think that the student-athletes would get some piece of action. But in fact, it's the student-athletes that can barely cover their costs even with a full-ride scholarship. The hypocrisy that is the NCAA doesn't allow it's students to be sponsored, yet the NCAA sells almost every piece of itself to sweatshop outfits like NIKE, Reebok and Adidas. Something is wrong when the NCAA won't even permit students to get a part-time job on campus forcing many to live in student ghettos.
What about a Free Education?
Unless you receive an athletic scholarship to play at an Ivy League school (of which almost none are competitive in either Football or Basketball with the mild exception of Stanford in Basketball), an undergraduate degree from Canada is just as good if not better that the majority of public or private universities in the US. At least in Canada, schools still pride themselves in their student-athletes academic acheivements. In contrast, a published report by the NCAA showed that recent BCS National Champion LSU graduates only 40 percent of its football players, Oklahoma a pitiful 33 percent. In fact, if schools were required to graduate 50 percent of it's student-athletes, 26 of 28 Bowl games would've been cancelled in 2004. What kind of education are you really getting when student-athletes are faced with waking up for 8am classes after getting back at 3am from a weeknight away game so that ESPN can fill their College Gamenight primetime schedule. Thanks, but no thanks.
I want to go Pro
One of the most idiotic rules ever instituted was the age restriction rule put in place by both the NFL and now the NBA. From a money standpoint, it's great. The pro leagues have a free minor-league system called the NCAA to milk and exploit the "student-athletes" before they get to the pros. If a kid is good enough to go pro, why not go straight from high-school?? With scouting as good as it has ever been, it's the All-Americans that are the ones going pro even after college anyways. The reality nowadays is, if you're not good enough to get to the pros coming out of high school (ie. ranked on Scout.com), you can forget playing in the NFL or NBA.
Closing Thoughts
Don't get me wrong, I love watching College Football and Basketball. The entertainment value is unquestionable, the games are thrilling, the rivalries unmatched, but it stinks from an educational perspective. Money is the ultimate corruptor, the networks and corporate sponsors will do anything and everything to make more of it especially at the expense of you and your education. Are Canadian schools perfect? Hell no. Do I think Canadian schools should offer full-ride scholarships? Absolutely, it's the least they can do to help struggling student-athletes pay the bills. After all, it's not like they're part of the Physics club or something, they're elite athletes for christ's sake. I say, play your sport at a high level, get an education, choose Canada.
As always, post your take or email it to me at BCSportsFanatic@yahoo.ca.
8 Comments:
At 7:38 PM, May 20, 2006, Anonymous said…
If a kid is good enough to go pro, why not go straight from high-school??
Are you kidding me?
At 2:12 AM, May 21, 2006, BCSportsFanatic said…
Why the hell not??
In MLB, all the top prospects are chosen from high school. Trajan Langdon was part of Padres Spring Training while playing 4 years for Duke Basketball.
The NHL drafts all of it's top prospects out of Junior hockey (U19 last time I checked). Sidney Crosby couldn't order a beer when he started last fall for the Pens.
We send kids right out of high school to get blown up by Afghanis in the "War on Terror", yet we don't allow them to play a game for money??
Are YOU kidding me???
At 4:31 PM, May 26, 2006, Anonymous said…
A couple thoughts to add... Football is a complex game that takes time to develop in... its one of the few games that experiance actually counts for something. It takes time for 99.9% of the athletes in the world to get to the strength and speed of the pro level. inorder to be successful at the pro level you must take small steps ie. high school, college/junior, then if you developed the right way you can have a crack at the pros. I 100% dissagree with that comment of high school players going straight to pros... if Reggie bush couldnt do it... which no way he could have... then nobody can. ALSO it sets a bad example for the athletes. By not letting them go straight into the pros you are giving them the oppertunity to attend university and hopefully get a degree.
another thing... about the full ride deal in Canada. It really isnt needed. School in Canada costs no more then 15,000 a year. On average you are looking at about 10 - 12 thousand a year... this uncludes meal plan, full course load, and houseing. With the partial scholarships available to student athletes you can cut that expense down to about 6,000 a year for houseing and food. Most Canadian schools require fairly high academic averages so if you are smart enough to get into a field of study you should beable to obtain a academic scholarship somewhere in your community or from the school. Now lets say you go to a school with football in your city and can live at home + have an athletic scholarship now all you have to pay for is books which cant be anymore then 1500 a year. American schools are WAY more expensive and for most people you would need to get a full ride to beable to afford schooling.
Bottom line is... if you are a smart student and are good enough to get a athletic scholarship in canada then you shouldnt need to worry about money.
At 12:28 AM, May 27, 2006, Anonymous said…
I was a 4.0 student out of high school, took a rigorous course of studies (engineering), and played football for four years at university (received athletic funding each year). I worked my butt off in the summers, part-time in the spring, and scrimped and saved. I still left school (12 credits short but with a healthy job offer in my field of study) with $32,000 in debt - and that was in the late 90's, when tuition was much cheaper than now. To say that good student athletes need not worry about money is simply a ludicrous statement not based in reality.
I'm encouraged to see that CIS schools are now able to offer more comprehensive funding to deserving student athletes.
On another note, I'm very glad I did not pursue the opportunities I had stateside, as the quality of education that I received at home far exceeded anything that all but the top academic US schools could offer.
At 4:52 PM, May 27, 2006, Anonymous said…
about people going to NFL out of high school is ridiculous... most of your knowledge and training for football will come from university... not some high school coach who does it for free
At 11:23 PM, May 27, 2006, Anonymous said…
many of us are wondering what the best football scholarships are, here at SFU or UBC?
At 8:13 AM, May 28, 2006, Anonymous said…
Scholarships in Canada can potentially cover the full costs of Tuition and Fees. Leaving the Student athlete with the cost of Books, and room and board. Unless of course the athlete is staying at home while studying at the university... Which is the best thing to do because you get the home cooked meals giving you a much more balanced diet (important for athletes) and you probably wont get cought up in the party every night and skipping classes as much like some do when they live in dorms. If you live in vancouver area then you should STRONGLY consider attending UBC or SFU.
At 12:37 AM, July 12, 2006, Anonymous said…
Hi Friend! You have a great blog over here!
Please accept my compliments and wishes for your happiness and success!
If you have a moment, please take a look at my at risk students site.
Have a great day!
Post a Comment
<< Home